top of page

Jimmie Nicol’s 10 Days as a Beatle: A Brush with Fame, Followed by a Lifetime in Shadows

Writer's picture: Zac WildeZac Wilde

In June 1964, fate took an unexpected turn for small-time drummer Jimmie Nicol. When Ringo Starr fell ill with tonsillitis just before The Beatles’ first world tour, the band faced a daunting decision: cancel the tour or find a replacement drummer.

The Beatles, L-R: George Harrison, Paul McCartney, John Lennon, and temporary drummer Jimmie Nicol, performing on television at Treslong in Hillegom, Netherlands, June 5, 1964.
The Beatles, L-R: George Harrison, Paul McCartney, John Lennon, and temporary drummer Jimmie Nicol, performing on television at Treslong in Hillegom, Netherlands, June 5, 1964.

Despite reservations, manager Brian Epstein ultimately convinced George Harrison to agree to the temporary stand-in, thrusting Nicol into a surreal role. Over the next ten days, Nicol would experience the rarest of privileges—being a Beatle—while touring Denmark, the Netherlands, Hong Kong, and Australia. But for Nicol, this brush with fame would come at a cost, leaving him adrift and forgotten.


With less than a day’s notice, Nicol received a phone call from Beatles’ producer George Martin, who famously asked, “What are you doing for the next four days?” Nicol’s life changed instantly, and he quickly made his way to Abbey Road Studios to meet his new bandmates. As Andrew Milton from the Parlogram YouTube channel explains, Nicol’s confidence and quick adaptability impressed the Beatles. He effortlessly ran through the setlist, including classics like "I Want to Hold Your Hand" and "She Loves You,” securing his spot on the tour. Nicol’s look was tweaked to match the band, even donning Ringo’s altered suits.

The Beatles arriving at Schiphol Airport, Netherlands, on June 5, 1964, standing on the aircraft steps above a crowd of jostling press photographers.
The Beatles arriving at Schiphol Airport, Netherlands, on June 5, 1964, standing on the aircraft steps above a crowd of jostling press photographers.

Nicol’s first encounter with “Beatlemania” happened in Copenhagen, where 6,000 fans greeted him and the band. Judith Simons of The Daily Express captured his disbelief and joy, describing how Nicol’s five-year-old son proudly told neighbours, “My daddy is a Beatle!” Nicol became an icon overnight, but his tenure in the band was always tenuous. Even as he and John Lennon bonded, Nicol knew that his presence was temporary. Yet the allure of the spotlight was irresistible. By the time they arrived in Sydney to an overwhelming crowd of 300,000 people, Nicol began entertaining the notion of a permanent place in the Beatles.


Buy The Beatles

1964 US Albums In Mono (Box Set)



As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect your price.


However, with Ringo’s health improving, Nicol’s days as a Beatle were numbered. Upon arriving in Melbourne, Nicol shared a bittersweet handshake with Ringo. During a press conference, he attempted to maintain his newfound fame, reportedly discussing a future tour with jazz singer Frances Faye. His attempt at independence backfired, as Epstein instructed Nicol to return to London without fanfare. Milton notes Nicol’s iconic departure, with Nicol sitting alone at the airport, awaiting a flight home and a symbolic gold watch inscribed, “To Jimmie with appreciation and gratitude.”


As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect your price.

Jim Berkenstadt - The Beatle Who Vanished: 60th Beatles Anniversary Tour Version

Despite his hopes, Jimmy Nicol struggled to parlay his Beatles connection into a lasting career. He joined the band Shubdubs and briefly filled in for the Dave Clark Five, but commercial success eluded him. As Milton recounts, Nicol eventually relocated to Mexico and faded from public view, though his son later worked on The Beatles Anthology. When asked by Paul McCartney if he could reconnect with Nicol, his son simply replied, “No.”


Nicol’s brief tenure as a Beatle remains a captivating but tragic tale, a testament to the fleeting nature of fame. While Roy Orbison’s son Alex acquired the rights to Nicol’s story in 2017, a film adaptation remains unrealised. For those intrigued by this “temporary Beatle,” Milton suggests Jim Berkenstadt’s book The Beatles Who Vanished, a detailed exploration of Nicol’s life and legacy.




Buy Jim Berkenstadt:

The Beatle Who Vanished (hardcover book)




As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect your price.

86 views

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

  • Facebook logo
  • Instagram
  • X logo
  • YouTube logo

© 2024-2025 Pop Preservation Society Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.

Images throughout this website are licensed from respective copyright holders. No endorsement implied.

This website contains affiliate links. See our Affiliate Disclosure for more information.

bottom of page